Shrinkies are interesting characters. I have a couple in my personal herd and enjoy them. We've also sold quite a few over the years, and I've saved their photos to help answer hobbyist questions. Today we had a question about how to care for shrinkies from Charlie in the UK, so it seems like a great time to talk about them.
Never heard of shrinkies? "Shrinky" is a term coined by Breyer collectors for models that have shrunk in size to become smaller than most models on their mold. Breyer models are made of the same material as old movie film reels, and old films suffer from this same type of plastic separation and breakdown, which film archivists call vinegar symdrome, after the noticeable smell that comes when you open an old film canister.
A great example is this shrinky Precipitado Sin Par next to a non-shrinky one:
Shrinkies usually are found among models made from the mid-1980s to the mid-1990s, when Breyer first started moving production to China. Without getting technical, it's believed that the batches of plastic used during that time weren't accurately mixed, resulting in a different percentage of one chemical versus others. [Fun fact: Did you know that Breyer's plastic (cellulose acetate) is not made from petroleum products, but instead is sourced from wood and cotton?]
Not every model made during this era is a shrinky, probably because Breyer had some blank models left in their warehouses from earlier production, and also because they didn't move all molds to China at the same time. You can tell shrinkies in a few ways, though they won't all show all the symptoms... Some depend on the severity of the shrinkage.
Check out this adorable shrinky Family Foal!
In early stages, all you'll see is that they're smaller. This is the cute stage - The stage we want to keep them at if we can.
What you don't want to start seeing is this:
Another thing that can happen is color fading. Compare the shrinky Secretariat's color to a "normal" Secretariat:
We're not sure exactly how this works chemically, but colors, particularly browns, fade on shrinkies that are deep into the process. You can also sometimes see a white powdery coating on the horse's body, as seen below on this same model:
I think this may happen after the oily stuff sits on the plastic for a while and evaporates, but that's only a guess. This guy is still attached in his original box, but was kept in an airtight container in storage for several years.
White models also change color somewhat, though it's harder to describe. The Leopard Appy Fighter pictured below (as well as the stripe and socks on the Family Foal at the top), and other models we've had with white areas, look more "solid" or opaque than usual, often duller, and some even have a very slight greyish or yellowish tint... just enough for you to notice that there's something different about them.
You can see that on the Fighter - He has been sunbathed, so it's not yellowing you see. In person, it's more of a dingy greyish cast to the plastic, most likely caused by the plastic condensing as it shrinks. This condensing can also - at the worst stages - cause legs to bend and entire bodies to start to look "lumpy" as some areas shrink more quickly than others.
Here's the worst we've seen. This Rugged Lark has had a bad time of it, and shows all of the symptoms:
Not only is he quite a bit smaller than he was originally, and his color has faded from a rich red bay to this pale version, he's showing the twisting legs and lumpy body shape of severe degradation. Check out his hind legs:
And here's a view from underneath to show the lumpiness of his profile.
Sounds scary, especially if you have models in storage, but it doesn't have to get that bad!
Air flow is definitely a key to slowing this process and maybe halting it altogether. Displaying shrinkies on open shelves in a room that has moving air is the best thing for them. I have a shrinky Adios in red dun in my own herd:
His run was 1988-1989. I bought him around 1993 without realizing he was a shrinky, and have displayed him on open shelves ever since (see below). He is considerably smaller than his brothers, shorter in length and narrower. If you look closely, you'll see that he has deeper hollows at the girth and flanks. However, he has never gotten oily or had problems with twisting legs.. My Horse Room is in the loft of our Cape Cod-style home, so it's open through the railing right down to the living room, providing lots of air flow.
As you can see, he's right in there with all his brothers (he's wearing a halter in this photo from 2014), so I can vouch positively that vinegar syndrome is not contagious. It's simply the breaking down of a poorly mixed batch of plastic, so either a horse was made with a poor mix that will shrink and condense over time, or it wasn't. They're perfectly safe to have around others. The Black Beauty in this article was in a tote with dozens of other models, but despite how bad he was, no other horses in the tote were affected.
However, the key to slowing the process is good air circulation, so if you can display yours on open shelves instead of behind glass, that will help a lot. And while nothing has been said about this officially, cool temps and low humidity are certainly also factors in keeping these special guys safe. To preserve old films, they keep them in vaults at temps just above freezing and with very low humidity, so it makes sense to try to keep our models out of extreme heat and humidity as well. Our home gets pretty warm in summer, and used to get humid (no longer, now that we have heat pumps), which is probably why my Adios shrunk as much as he has. Triple Mountain keeps models we have for sale in cool, low-humidity storage for that same reason.
If you have to keep your models in storage for a period of time, try to keep them in a cool, low humidity location and ideally don't use airtight containers. They are best kept wrapped in soft, white cotton fabric (old, clean cotton t-shirts are great, as are some bed sheets or white towels - Never anything colored, though, as dyes can bleed into plastic over time), which breathes better than plastic. If it's safe to do so, you might want to consider using cardboard boxes instead of plastic totes, or drilling some small vent holes into the totes.
[Above - A rarely seen peek into Triple Mountain's Model Storage]
Of course, if there's a chance that your models might be exposed to moisture while in storage, it would be wiser to risk vinegar syndrome in the few models that may be prone to it, than to have an entire box full of models get moldy... So use your judgement based on the situation and try to get them back out into open air as soon as possible.
There you go - I hope you learned a bit about shrinkies! They add a lot of character to our collections and represent an interesting period in Breyer history. With proper care, they can continue to do so for many more decades.
And on a happy note: All of the shrinky models shown here have found happy new homes!
Interesting. I just found that one of my cows that I’m trying to sell, is a shrinky. No signs, other than height difference. But it’s a pretty big difference. Do you know if there is a FaceBook group for Shrinkies? But anyways, thank you so much for the article.
Hi, I want to thank you for these articles! I have a HUGE collection of not only model horses, but Barbies and other 1:6 scale figures (vintage & newer), 1/6 scale vehicles, plastic doll furniture, and Hartlands and Breyer horses! My point is, they ALL have the same thing in common.,. PLASTIC. I think these problems you mention that happen to the model horses, can and DO happen with ALL other plastic items. It would be great if someone with some vast knowledge of chemistry (chemical engineering perhaps) could help advise? Although I’m afraid they’d say “get rid of our collections NOW!!” 😬 Plastics are all around us in everyday use in our homes, work, schools, in our drink and food containers, and even in some clothing, etc.! No wonder there’s a high rate of Cancer and various other health & environmental problems!! I hope this discussion gets more attention from others. I’d like to hear if anyone with a chemistry degree knows more, or can add to this subject, because I see this problem with various collectors of different items made of plastic asking the same type of questions almost every week!!
Thank you for an interesting article! I’ve been collecting for a long time, so had heard (and seen) these older shrinkies. But what about more recent models that show similar size differences? For example, I’ve noticed that my Valentine (Giselle mold) is noticeably smaller than the Slainte Surprise models; and the Breyerfest Marwari Nazruddin is significantly larger than the palomino Marwari. No other signs have yet appeared, and they live on open shelves, but since they are newer molds, I wonder if this is a similar issue or something else entirely….?
Thanks for this! I have about 2-3 shrinking but luckily not any with oil in them, my moms had been in a plastic box but they are fine luckily. They were there for 3y.
Ouch, Ellen, that’s so sad! I’m so sorry for you! And you too Tonya! I store my models in a temperature controlled house with open air and frequent “health” checks.